Tesla investors try to look past Elon Musk’s many, many distractions
A version of this story first appeared in CNN Business’ Before the Bell newsletter. Not a subscriber? You can sign up right here.
Elon Musk now wants to buy Twitter after all. While that’s good news for Twitter’s long-suffering shareholders, Tesla investors hope he still has some time for them. They need a little help, too.
Sure, Musk still has many fans on Wall Street and behind the wheel. But some are growing tired of how the world’s richest person can’t focus more on the company that has provided him with the bulk of his wealth.
(TSLA) reports earnings after the close on Wednesday. Shares are down more than 35% this year amid concerns about the fact that Tesla
(TSLA) recently reported weaker production and delivery numbers than expected for the third quarter.
Wall Street still expects extremely strong sales and earnings growth, with consensus forecasts calling for a more than a 60% jump in revenue and profit. But analysts have been trimming those estimates in the past few weeks.
That’s partly due to the fact that Tesla faces growing competition in the United States from the likes of GM
(VLKAF) and other electric vehicle upstarts such as Rivian and Lucid.
There are big challenges in China as well, with Tesla going up against homegrown EV rivals like Nio
(NIO), Xpeng and Li Auto. There’s also BYD, a Chinese auto firm backed by Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway
To be fair, the entire auto sector is struggling this year due to growing worries about a global recession, surging energy prices and, of course, brutal competition.
All the major US, European and Japanese car maker stocks are down about 20% to 45% this year. And shares of the pure play EV companies (both in the US and China) have each plunged about 60% to 80% in 2022.
Gary Black, managing partner at the Future Fund and a Tesla shareholder, has been tweeting for the past few weeks that concerns about Twitter are a headache for Tesla investors.
In one tweet, Black said there are several problems for Tesla due to Twitter. Two of the biggest? The overhang from an eventual Tesla stock sale by Musk to finance the deal and the distraction for Musk, especially since “Elon’s core competency is engineering/tech” and Twitter is more of an ad-driven media business.
Tesla also has no chief operating officer. That means Musk has to take a hands-on approach at Tesla while also being distracted by his numerous other pursuits, such as SpaceX, The Boring Company, Neuralink and potentially Twitter
The underwhelming deliveries and production numbers also underscore how a slowing global economy (and possible recession) could hurt Tesla.
“Are we sure the problem is only supply and not (partially) related to demand?” asked Morgan Stanley analyst Adam Jonas in a recent report.
Jonas added, saying it “would be unreasonable to assume” that the company can keep raising prices without demand suffering, especially if the economy is slowing.
Demand could also take a hit as Tesla faces even more competition in the US.
“To enhance its competitive position, Tesla will need to expand its range of products to contend with a substantially higher number of models from established global automakers and start-ups by the end of 2025,” said analysts at S&P Global Ratings in a recent report.
The S&P analysts are confident Musk can pull this off. They even recently upgraded their credit rating on Tesla. But they conceded that it won’t be easy. The margin of error is slim. S&P estimates the number of electric vehicle models available in North America will exceed 100 by 2026, more than four times current levels.
“Over the next 3-5 years, a few of these could become formidable competitors for Tesla,” the analysts said.
Netflix investors know a thing or two about what can happen when a market you were once the clear leader in goes mainstream. Shares of the streaming giant have plunged more than 60% in 2022, making it one of the worst performers in the S&P 500.
The company will report third-quarter earnings on Tuesday, and investors will be watching to see if Netflix
(NFLX) is able to stem the bleeding after losing subscribers in each of the first two quarters.
Netflix’s woes have led the company to do what was previously unthinkable: announce plans last Thursday for a cheaper subscription plan supported by advertising. Netflix will launch the ad-based version (also known as old-fashioned television) in November. It’s a bold decision that may not pan out.
“We see the move to offer an ad supported tier by the global streaming incumbent player as defensive not offensive and fraught with…risk that continues to be underappreciated,” said Jeffrey Wlodarczak, an analyst with Pivotal Research Group who has a “sell” rating on the stock.
Recession worries are leading many consumers to cut back on how much they plan to spend on streaming services, of which there are now legion. That’s bad news in particular for Netflix.
Goldman Sachs analyst Eric Sheridan, who also has a “sell” on Netflix, said in a report that he remains “concerned that additional subscriber offerings could cause ‘spin down’ into the lowest priced plans by users in any potential consumer recession over the next 6-12 months.” In other words, users ditch the more expensive plans for less profitable, cheaper subscriptions.
What’s more, Netflix is no longer the only streaming game that is struggling. Shares of Disney
(DIS), which also has an ad-based version for Disney
(DIS)+ coming soon, are down nearly 40% this year.
In addition to Netflix and Disney+, there is also Disney-controlled Hulu, Amazon’s
(AMZN) Prime Video, Apple
(AAPL) TV+, Peacock, Paramount+ and HBO Max. (CNN parent Warner Bros. Discovery owns HBO Max.)
Economic slowdown jitters have hit the entire media sector hard, as investors worry that consumers will balk at paying for more monthly subscriptions and corporate advertising budgets will also dry up.
Shares of Peacock owner Comcast
(CMCSA), Paramount and Warner Bros. Discovery are all down about 40% to 50% this year.
Monday: Earnings from Bank of America
(BAC), Charles Schwab
(SCHW) and BNY Mellon
Tuesday: US industrial production; China GDP; earnings from Johnson & Johnson
(JNJ), Goldman Sachs
(GS), Albertsons, Lockheed Martin
(TFC), State Street
(UAL) and Netflix
Wednesday: US housing starts; UK and Europe inflation; earnings from Procter & Gamble
(PG), Abbott Labs
(TRV), Baker Hughes
(BKR), M&T Bank
(MTB), Ally Financial
(ALLY), Citizens Financial
(CFG), Northern Trust
(WGO), Tesla, IBM
(IBM) and Alcoa
Thursday: US weekly jobless claims; US existing home sales; earnings from Ericsson
(T), American Airlines
(DOW), Philip Morris
(PM), Union Pacific
(UNP), Alaska Air
(SNAP) and Boston Beer
Friday: Japan inflation; earnings from Verizon
(VZ), American Express
(HCA) and Schlumberger